For the second challenge, the remaining contestants were paired up and had to give their take on new Food Network titles: Ooey Gooey, Cheat Eats and Stacked Snacks. It was decided that Amy did the best for the first challenge, so she had the advantage of picking the title of her show and was also able to pick the teams. Everybody was judged by Bobby, Giada, and guest judges Loni Love and Alex Guarnaschelli.
The judges decided that Katie, Palak, and Manny did the best in the challenge and they were all safe. It was decided that Jess would be eliminated from the competition and she was sent home and to Star Salvation.
On Star Salvation Jason Goldstein, Chris Valdes, Harrison Bader and Jess Tom were competing. This episode of Star Salvation can be watched here, and the judges decided to eliminate Jason Goldstein from this episode. Jason Goldstein will not be rejoining the competition and will not be the next Food Network Star.